OSU faculty committee says Hargis should consult researchers before dropping projects

OSU Update

Discussion

January 20, 2010

Members agree Oklahoma State president has authority to refuse research projects

By Sarah Morris Stillwater NewsPress The Stillwater News Press Wed Jan 20, 2010, 11:48 AM CST

STILLWATER, Okla. — A six-member research committee says Oklahoma State administrators should meet with faculty on animal research policies.

The committee’s recommendation follows President Burns Hargis’ refusal of a federally funded project involving anthrax vaccine and baboons. Hargis’ decision to turn away the project stirred criticism on and off campus.

The research committee is part of OSU’s Faculty Council.

“This controversy does raise questions specific to research involving nonhuman primates, and we believe that the president should engage with the faculty and appropriate administrators regarding future policies,” an 11-page committee finding said.

The committee found that Hargis had the authority to not participate in the project involving the effects of anthrax on baboons with the primates euthanized afterward.

In the project, OSU and its animal biosecurity level 3 facility at the Center of Veterinary Health Sciences would have served as a fee-for-service vendor to the Oklahoma Medical Research Foundation and Boston University.

The Faculty Council research committee began the project a month ago at the Faculty Council’s request. Dr. James E. Smay, the committee’s chairman, said recently the committee determined the extent of scientific merit review, and administrative and logistical issues.

The report included issues such as OSU not yet being accredited by the Association for the Assessment and Accreditation of Laboratory Animal Care International, which was not a requirement for the proposed research, and Boston University’s refusal to add the principal investigator (and their employee) Dr. Shinichiro Kurosawa to their select agents and toxins registration with the Centers for Disease Control.

The administrative and logistical issues were the primary reasons for Hargis’ decision, according to the report. The report said important pathogen research should be conducted carefully with the highest possible standards such as accreditation.

“We believe these facts support this assertion by the president and provide reasonable basis for the decision he made. We acknowledge that reasonable persons may observe the same evidence and reach a different conclusion,” the report read. “We further assert that the president’s decision was made without sufficient consultation with the faculty or the responsible administration.”

The report found Hargis’ decision to deny the project flawed in two ways. There was insufficient consultation with appropriate stakeholders and the report cited “sweeping statements signifying a change in OSU policy without any faculty input.”

However, the report said Hargis acknowledged the mistake of not communicating well with all faculty while the latter was corrected shortly after.

Text Only

OSU Update

Occupy OSU Stillwater group heads to Oklahoma Capitol for weekend demonstration
Anti-Wall Street protesters will be gathering at statehouses nationwide Saturday, and a group of Oklahoma State University students will be among them.

October 28, 2011
PHOTOS: Harvest Carnival 2011 in Stillwater
October 26, 2011 14 Photos
State department program brings Kenyan and Ugandan visitors to Oklahoma, Stillwater
A group of Kenyan and Ugandan journalists, policy makers and community leaders are wrapping up a visit to Oklahoma State University this week as a part of a U.S. State Department initiative aimed at tackling food security issues in developing nations.

October 14, 2011
Former NBA player Desmond Mason is Oklahoma State University Homecoming grand marshal
October 13, 2011 1 Photo
Alumnae of Oklahoma State University's Alpha Omicron Chapter of Alpha Delta Pi celebrating in Stillwater
September 23, 2011
NEW: OSU/A&M Regents to discuss conference realignment Wednesday
The OSU/A&M Board of Regents will hold a special meeting at 2 p.m. Wednesday to discuss "matters relating to athletic conference membership," officials announced in a release Monday.

September 19, 2011
Oklahoma State professor shares South Africa research experience
Heidi Hoffer, an OSU theater professor and Fulbright Scholar, spent 13 months doing research in South Africa. Hoffman gave a lecture on her experiences Wednesday.

September 1, 2011
Stillwater artist casts two-time Gov. Henry Bellmon in bronze for Oklahoma State research center
Oklahoma State University officials plan to hold a dedication ceremony for the research center Sept. 9.

August 30, 2011 2 Photos
Oklahoma State University's Lights on Stillwater shows students what city has to offer
August 25, 2011 6 Photos
Oklahoma State University's Student Union renovations continue as fall semester begins
Mitch Kilcrease walked down a flight of stairs at the Oklahoma State University Student Union Thursday afternoon to find a family with confused looks on their faces.

August 22, 2011 5 Photos
More OSU Update Headlines

OSU Update

Search Results

Discussion

OSU faculty committee says Hargis should consult researchers before dropping projects

Members agree Oklahoma State president has authority to refuse research projects

Site Map

Contact Us